Thu, 22 Oct 2020

Getting back to the roots of spycraft

Independent Australia
21 Sep 2020, 12:52 GMT+10

Security agencies are now accustomed to high-tech spying methods, but old-fashioned techniques required getting down and dirty, writes Bruce Haigh.

THERE IS, or there should be, more to spying than high-tech electronics. As we have seen, high-tech can get agencies into trouble; it can lead to dead ends and bear pits. We need to get back to basics, feet on the ground. In this piece, I look at information gathering as once practised. Our high-tech security agencies are making a complete hash of our relationship with China.

There has been a lot of talk of spies and spying recently, particularly in the Murdoch press and amongst Right-wing camp followers. The Right is enthralled, enamoured and thoroughly seduced by the notion of spying.

Just as boys and girls with leanings toward the Right tend to join the armed forces, so do Right-leaning youngsters get recruited as spies.

A spy is a person employed by a government to obtain secret information or intelligence about another country and individuals within it. Spies come in many shapes and forms. They can be full or part-time, they can be sleepers, activated as needed. Or even members of professional or sporting associations and academics who report regularly or as required, or when they judge something is of interest to their minder. They might be journalists, but they shouldn't be. Sometimes diplomats are spies; sometimes spies use the cover of diplomacy to undertake their activities.

MUNGO MACCALLUM: ASIO and Left versus Right extremist threats

The ASIO boss has belatedly acknowledged that rightwing extremism poses a threat to society - perhaps he might now tell us what he plans to do about it.

During a posting to South Africa, as Second Secretary in the Australian Embassy, I was spied on. I was followed and my phone was tapped, the reason being that I had contact with Black South Africans including the Black Consciousness Movement (BCM), who was rightly regarded by the White regime as hostile to apartheid. The apartheid regime believed the BCM was sympathetic to the banned South African Communist Party (SACP).

Many of the people I met with were monitored, observed or under full-time surveillance, including Steve Biko, the leader of the BCM, who was murdered by the police in September 1977. It subsequently emerged that the regime thought I was a spy, no doubt in light of my contact with the BCM and Blacks opposed to apartheid, particularly as none of my diplomatic colleagues developed a network.

Under these circumstances, maybe I was a spy, although not recruited or appointed by Canberra. The networks I maintained and the circumstances under which they were maintained were those that might have been deployed by a spy in terms of secrecy and subterfuge protecting Black political activists and informers from association with me.

Certainly, that is what the South African Government were convinced of when they tried to have me expelled in 1979, but it backfired. In any case, without having set out to do so, I became conversant with the craft of spying. I knew the mood of the townships and sometimes plans which extended beyond them.

The CIA and MI6 worked closely with the Bureau of State Security (B.O.S.S.) in seeking to prevent "the downward thrust of communism" in Southern Africa. The Americans believed it, the British did not. When a British MI6 operative learnt of my activities in helping people cross the border, he organised visas from the British High Commission. This was not part of his official brief.

Representatives of the CIA, MI6, B.O.S.S. and the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) used to meet for lunch once a month in Canberra in the late '80s and early '90s. Why? To discuss communism? The evils of the anti-apartheid movement? Or did they feel themselves part of an elite, a select band of brothers?

Security agencies insert members into large corporations with overseas interests. This may be on a long or short-term basis. Some may even be permanent employees. Former Prime Minister John Howard was guilty of inadvertently but naively causing agencies major problems.

During a posting to Saudi Arabia as First Secretary, my phone was tapped. An embassy-based CIA agent told me that when an American company set up the Saudi telephone system, the CIA bugged it. The Americans knew everything the Saudis were saying. Much as they did with the Collins class submarines, they can be tracked worldwide. Don't worry about the Chinese, Big Brother has got Australia well and truly covered with Pine Gap playing an important role.

Pine Gap FOI bombshell: Australia has 'full knowledge and concurrence'

New FOI documents appear to show Australia has full knowledge of US activities at Pine Gap, which may have serious ramifications for the nation.

In the course of a posting to Pakistan, after I had become a confidant and friend of the future Prime Minister of Pakistan, Benazir Bhutto, my phone was tapped and I was followed. Of course, developing a relationship with Benazir was a legitimate and proper undertaking for the diplomatic Counsellor at the Australian Embassy.

What was not quite so regular was for me to take photos of Russian soldiers, tanks, radio communications, trucks and bases in Kabul during three monthly visits from Islamabad in the period 1986 to 1988. The Joint Intelligence Organisation (JIO) in Canberra supplied a magnificent little camera with a hot shoe and lots of film. And they expressed themselves happy with the results.

Kabul was a city under siege from the Mujahideen. Entering the office of some diplomatic colleagues, fear was palpable. Fear has a distinctive smell - rank, tinny and slightly fishy. I knew it from South Africa. Fear does strange things. The only way I could go to sleep in our beautiful little dacha in Kabul was lying on my back so I could "see" the rocket or mortar that came through the roof.

In 1987, I met the Polish First Secretary at the airport when flying from Delhi to Kabul. I made arrangements to call on him. The weather was cool. He had a jumper on. Underneath the jumper was a "box". We talked. He was cautious, but clearly had a lot more to say. I organised a lunch party at home. Behind a high wall, the house had a lovely garden with almond and apricot trees and a terrace which overlooked them. On that, I placed a trestle table with dishes of salad, chicken, fresh bread and many bottles of Vodka. I invited our Western as well as some of our East European friends and the Chinese but not the Russians.

After a time, I asked my Polish colleague what the box under his jumper was and he said it was a recording device. I said his technology was crap and he laughed. He wanted to talk. We quickly established a rapport and I said anything he could pass on about the Russians would be great and he did - the Poles were fed up with the Russians. He eventually arranged for me to meet with them.

#HeyASIO: Is it me you're looking for?

The war on terror and the arduous job of collecting everyone's personal data is a very serious business indeed, says Dr Martin Hirst (AKA @ethicalmartini), which makes it all the more important we take the piss out of it relentlessly.

The Chinese and Indians had good information about the Russians but the Chinese knew more and were happy to share with Australians. They had a big and well-equipped embassy. They understood the difficulties of a fly-in-fly-out Australian diplomat and had me to dinner at least twice during a ten-day visit, all on the basis of the strong relationship established by Prime Minister Gough Whitlam in 1972.

The British Embassy in Kabul was staffed mainly by MI6 people and the U.S. Embassy by CIA. The U.S. Embassy in Islamabad was responsible for over 600 "aid workers" based in Peshawar, Quetta and inside Afghanistan. They were involved in training and supplying the Mujahideen. A friend in Peshawar who worked with MI6 was married to a Frenchman who took photographs inside Afghanistan - he was a spy. He was shot at the back door of his house in Peshawar with an AK-47 by a person dressed as a Pathan.

His wife later married a man who had been through Sandhurst and worked with the British SAS in their operations across the border in support of the brilliant Mujahideen leader, Massoud. He was later killed in Russia when working as a journalist, widowing his wife for a second time.

An Australian working for a journal based in Asia accompanied me to a meeting in Peshawar with Gulbuddin Hekmatyar, an unsavoury and untrustworthy Mujahideen leader. He somewhat blew his cover when a report turned up in our diplomatic bag from one of our agencies reporting the meeting.

The Russian assistant defence attache in Islamabad was shot dead as his car slowed at a corner near our Embassy and it was at a reception at the Russian Embassy that I learnt from an Indian diplomat, who was also the senior Research and Analysis Wing (R.A.W.) agent that General Zia had been blown up half an hour earlier in his air force Hercules. It was impressed upon me that although the aircraft had come down close to the border, the Indian Government was not involved. R.A.W. believed it was a group of middle-ranking Pakistan army officers who were behind it and they were right. My interlocuter, knowing of my relationship with Benazir, wanted that information conveyed to her, which I did within a short space of time.

Spying requires boots on the ground, getting down and dirty and first-hand observation. People heading intelligence agencies with only screen and cyber experience don't know the half of it. Others have claimed their leather seats by political brown-nosing and cruising corridors. But more on that later.

Bruce Haigh is a former Australian diplomat and a political commentator. You can follow Bruce on Twitter @bruce_haigh.

More Pakistan News

Access More

Sign up for Pakistan News

a daily newsletter full of things to discuss over drinks.and the great thing is that it's on the house!